Skip to content

Learn/Basics

Black and white koji make acid, and the acid is what lets a shochu mash survive the heat of Kyushu.

·

Honkaku shochu was originally enjoyed mainly in Kyushu, Hayashi and four co-authors write in the Journal of Fungi in 2021. The easy explanations are the sweet potatoes and the trade routes. The reason is smaller. It is a mold, and the acid it makes.

The National Research Institute of Brewing (NRIB) gives a main reason for using black and white koji, “their high production of citric acid”, and says the acidity matters when making shochu in the warm south, in Okinawa and Kyushu.

Koji has two jobs

Koji is a culture of mold grown on grain. Its first job is to break starch into sugar, because yeast cannot ferment starch.

Its second job is citric acid, which keeps the starter culture and the main mash acidic. Hayashi and co-authors add a third job, flavor.

The acid is what holds the mash

Citric acid prevents the growth of contaminating microbes. Yeast resists acidic conditions. The Japan Sake and Shochu Makers Association (the makers association) puts the first mash at around pH 3, “the same as an apple”.

The koji room is run for the acid as well. The grain is held near 40°C while the mold grows, then cooled to around 30°C, because the lower temperature enhances citric acid production.

Shochu mash is warm. The starter culture runs 3 to 8 days at around 30°C, and the main mash peaks at 28 to 32°C. Hayashi and co-authors write that the low pH allows stable fermentation in the hot, humid climate of a Japanese summer, or in an open environment. Futagami's 2022 review says the same of white koji: its citric acid lowers the pH of the mash, prevents the growth of undesired microbes and enables stable production in relatively warm regions of Japan.

Yellow koji does not make the acid

Yellow koji is Aspergillus oryzae, the mold of sake. Until the early 1900s, koji for shochu was exclusively A. oryzae, because sake making with it was already developed. NRIB puts the end of yellow koji's extensive use for shochu at about 100 years ago.

A. oryzae strains cannot produce high amounts of organic acids. Outside Okinawa, wherever yellow koji was used, spoiled mash is thought to have been frequent, the National Tax Agency (NTA) says.

NTA calls the years from 1903 to the end of the Meiji era a time of trials to overcome spoiled mash in Kyushu. Two changes contributed greatly, in NTA's words: a second mash, where koji, water and yeast ferment first and the sweet potato goes in after, and black koji in place of yellow.

Black koji came up from Okinawa around 1910

Okinawa already had it. Black koji was traditionally used there for awamori.

NTA's survey says black koji was used in Okinawa in the Edo period. Its origin, and the time it came into use, have not been established. Hirohide Toyama of the University of the Ryukyus infers in the same report that A. luchuensis diverged about 600 years ago, around the start of the Ryukyu dynasty. For the date of first use, he says, no document survives.

In 1910 Genichiro Kawachi took a post as an engineer at the Kagoshima tax supervisory bureau. He and Kensuke Kanbe, an engineer at the Kagoshima prefectural industrial test station, focused on the citric acid of black koji and spread its use in sweet potato shochu. Quality rose and alcohol yield increased.

Hayashi and co-authors say Kagoshima breweries introduced black koji from Okinawa around 1910. The makers association gives 1912, in its timeline and on its English koji page.

From Kagoshima it spread. Black koji was in use in Kuma, the rice shochu district of Kumamoto, from about 1940.

White koji came out of the black, in 1918 or 1924

Kawachi found it. He was keeping black koji when he found, by chance, a strain with a white colony. He isolated it, made seed koji and brewed shochu, and the result was good.

NTA's survey text and the makers association give 1918. NTA's own chronology table prints the discovery in its 1924 row. The agency does not reconcile the two. The makers association does not agree with itself on where he worked. Its Japanese timeline, and NTA's chronology, name the Kumamoto Regional Taxation Bureau. Its English koji page names the Kagoshima Taxation Bureau.

The white mold is a mutant of the black. It keeps the black mold's starch-digesting activity and its citric acid productivity. In Kuma white koji was in use from about 1950, and in most distilleries from 1970.

Black koji sheds black spores. Koji making for sweet potato shochu could take a week, because the koji had to saccharify five times as much sweet potato as there was koji, and over a week the black spores scattered. By about 1945 white koji had spread, as a koji that did not blacken work clothes or the koji room.

One species, with many names

Inui isolated a black koji in 1901 and named it Aspergillus luchuensis, NTA's survey says. Others published names: A. batatae in 1907, A. awamori and A. aureus around 1910, A. saitoi and A. nakazawai in 1951.

In 2013 Hong and colleagues, in PLoS ONE, treated A. luchuensis, A. kawachii and A. acidus as one species and selected A. luchuensis as the correct name, on priority. They found that the neotype of A. awamori does not come from awamori fermentation. NTA's chronology lists the unification of the black koji's name under A. luchuensis, in place of A. awamori and others.

The white koji is now Aspergillus luchuensis mut. kawachii.

Two pairs to taste side by side

Some bottles carry the koji color in the name. Densuki Black Koji and Densuki White Koji are imo shochu from Suki Shuzo in Miyazaki. Isadaisen BLACK (black koji) and Isadaisen (white koji) are imo shochu from Oyama Shuzo in Kagoshima.

The what-is-shochu page has a section on koji color. Taste one pair next to each other.

Sources

Go further

Send this article

If something here is wrong, say so through the contact page and we will fix it, with the source that corrected us.